Episode 149 – Come Correct

Give me your keys, I’m taking over! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the case of Cayetano Santos Godino and the legend of the Flatwoods Monster. Plus: one gardener fights to decorate their lawn with coffins, another uncovers a mysterious gate covered in teeth, and a call for resources for an upcoming episode topic!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Cayetano Santos Godino
2. Cayetano shows police how he tied knots around victims
3. Reyna Vianicoff, who was set on fire
4. Jesualdo Giordano (final victim) and his mother
5. Cayetano’s final mugshot
6. Welcome sign to Flatwoods – “Home of the Green Monster”
7. Rendering of Flatwoods Monster based on Kathleen May’s description
8. Artist depiction of Monster encounter
9. One of five Flatwoods Monster chairs

July 14, 2021

Episode 148 – Hot Victorian Ghost Summer

Take that ’til you get more! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the Shark Arm Murders and The Trouble (aka the Ringcroft Poltergeist). Plus: the most metal baby names ever (for real), a dancing cactus with a dark secret goes viral, and everybody poops, but don’t be such a freak about it!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Bert and Ron Hobson
2. The tattoo on the arm found inside the shark
3. Jimmy Smith
4. Reginald Holmes
5. Patrick Brady
6. The dead tree that marks the Mackie property
7-9. “The Haunting of Ringcroft” illustrations from The Scots Magazine

July 7, 2021

Episode 147 – Pickle Skunk

You sank my Dazzleship! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Rogers Family Murders and the case of the Boy in the Box. Plus: a tech mogul can’t relate, bonding with Mother/Daughter Whitesnake Time, and next time give that skunk a dang pickle!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Jo (Joan), Michelle, and Christe Rogers
2. Hal Rogers
3. Detective Jim Kappel
4. The Rogers’ abandoned car
5. The billboard
6. Ivelisse Berrios-Beguerisse
7. Police flyer of Boy in the Box
8. Digital mock up of what the Boy in the Box would have looked like
9. Boy in the Box’s grave

July 5, 2021

BONUS: Swamp Witch Specialty

Surprise! As a summertime treat, we wanted to share one of our favourite episodes of our Patreon-exclusive mini episodes, “Spooky Snacks” with you all.

In this super-special, double-stuffed episode, Tyler and Johnny share the case of the Cokeville Elementary School Hostage Crisis (aka the Cokeville Miracle) and the legend of the Shirime. Plus, we do a quiz where we make a mysterious magic potion just to find out what it actually does… For the sake of science, of course!

This episode (Spooky Snacks #82) was recorded live on Zoom in front of an audience of Secret Society Spooky Bitches. Keep your eyes peeled for our next live Zoom episode on July 22, 2021.

Do today’s quiz along with us: “Brew Your Magic Potion and We’ll Reveal What It Does”

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. David Young
2. Doris being removed from the scene
3. The angel
4. Newspaper clipping featuring survivors
5. Original Buson illustration of the Shirime
6. Depiction of a Shirime encounter

June 30, 2021

Episode 146 – Chuckle Drawer

Whatever you do, don’t look behind the earlobes! This week Johnny and Tyler are covering a selection of freaky stories sent in by you Spooky Bitches. Prepare to get into some real-life stories of ghosts, stalkers, “spiny boys”, and so much more. Plus: the wheel of Drag Race continues turning, an exorcism at a Home Depot has folks talking, and a woman who lived 37 years with a Tiddlywink up her nose can finally breathe a sigh of relief.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

No photos from today’s episode!

June 23, 2021

Episode 145 – Teen Queen Igor

It’s an ode to the margarita! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the case of Michelina Lewandowska and the disappearance of Lars Mittank (part 2). Plus: a ghost that worships the dolls, Drag Race Down Under crowns a queen, and our new pop culture obsession (isn’t that right, Bondi?)

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Michelina Lewandowska
2. Marcin Karsprzak (aka Turd Burglar)
3. The box
4. Michelina’s ring
5. The site where Michelina was buried
6. Sandra Mittank with a photo of Lars
7. Age progression of Lars
8. Missing poster from 2021 w/updated age progression sketches

June 16, 2021

Episode 144 – Conspiracy School

Can I get a solemn owa owa? This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the disappearance of Lars Mittank (part one) and the deaths Tom & Eileen Lonergan. Plus: a man gets eaten by a whale and lives to tell, Froggyland may be coming to your hometown, and the most unholy way to achieve that beachy, piecey look with your hair.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Lars Mittank
2. Golden Sands Resort
3. Hotel Color
4. Lars running from the airport doctor’s office
5. Tom and Eileen Lonergan
6. Still from home footage taken by another passenger on the MV Outer Edge
7. The Lonergans’ passports
8. Eileen’s diving gear, recovered from the beach
9. Digital recreation of the diving slate left by the couple

June 9, 2021

Episode 143 – Glucose Guardian

Get it, you robot! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the kidnapping of Colleen Stan and the disappearance of Ada Constance Kent. Plus: a 17 year old literally pokes the bear, Ai-Da puts the art in artificial intelligence, and we celebrate our first review submitted in writing on an actual potato.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Colleen Stan before her abduction
2. Prosecutor with the head box Colleen was trapped in
3. The second full-size box Colleen was imprisoned in
4. Cameron Hooker
5. Janice Hooker
6. Colleen and Cameron at Colleen’s parents home
7. The contract
8. Young Ada Constance Kent (c. 1900)
9. Ada’s church cottage

June 2, 2021

Episode 142 – Rancid Venom

That’s some Devil’s book shit! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the murder of Bill Neville and the Watseka Wonder. Plus: living in a constant state of Pride, Canadian history resurfaces in a big way, and even we have to admit when there’s too much Drag Race happening right now.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. The Capitol Theatre in 1975
2. Bill Neville
3. Charles Jeffrey
4. Darrell Gene Ward
5. Lurancy Vennum
6. Mary Roff
7. The Roff Household
8. Lurancy later in life

May 26, 2021

Episode 141 – Darlingist

I’m gonna dance the examples! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the case of Edith Thompson and the death of Gaurav Tiwari. Plus: another scented Molotov cocktail courtesy of Goop, the final chapter for Mia Zapata’s murderer, and a body found in a papier-mâché dinosaur has everyone guessing.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Edith Thompson
2. Percy and Edith Thompson
3. Frederick Bywaters
4. Frederick, Percy, and Edith
5. Frederick, Percy, and Edith
6. Gaurav Tiwari
7. Gaurav Tiwari
8. Gaurav investigating the haunted asylum