Time to clean the jam off of your hands! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart and the legend of Resurrection Mary. Plus: a possible explanation for ghosts, queens everywhere, and the Satanic undertones of The Nanny.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com View this post on Instagram

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on May 21, 2019 at 9:07pm PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Cassie Jo Stoddart
2. Cassie on the morning of her murder, recorded by Brian Draper
3. Torey Adamcik and Brian Draper
4. One of the masks used by Adamcik and Draper
5. Frank Contreras, Cassie’s uncle, outside his home
6. Resurrection Cemetery Sign
7. Burnt bars that appeared after a Mary sighting
8. Mary Bregovy from news clipping about her death
9. Anna Marija Norkus

Call up your best frenemy! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the murder of Angel Melendez (the ‘Party Monster’ case) and the Great Amherst Mystery. Plus: secret attic roommates, getting Suspirious, and a quick chat about Drag Race.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on May 15, 2019 at 12:04am PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Michael Alig & Clara the Chicken
2. Club Kids/Disco 2000 trading cards
3. Poster for the ‘Blood Feast’ party
4. Angel Melendez
5. Alig today (Photo by Damon Winter)
6. Esther Cox
7. The Teed Cottage in Amherst
8. Walter Hubbell
9. The Great Amherst Mystery Mural

Have a happy moving-in day! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the creepy story of the Watcher and the case of Bill Allen. Plus: Gaysper the ghost goes viral, buying Aleister Crowley’s old house, and a bit of a BTK follow-up.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on May 8, 2019 at 3:08am PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. The Watcher house
2. Broaddus family
3. Back porch of the Watcher house
4. Poster for ‘The Watcher’ (no relation)
5. Young Bill Allen
6. Bill Allen later in life

Hope you like poems! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the elusive Chupacabra and one of the biggest wieners of all time, BTK. Plus: the Heavy Metal Knitting Championship, child drag queens, and a love letter to facekinis.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on May 1, 2019 at 1:00am PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Artist rendition of the original Chupacabra
2. Artist drawing of the original Chupacabra
3. Chupacabra (or coyote with mange)
4. Dennis Rader’s mugshot
5. Victims of BTK
6. Self portrait by Dennis Rader in bondage gear/mask
7. Letter sent from ‘Bill Thomas Killman’

Welcome to the Warrenapalooza! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the Smurl Family haunting and the trial of Arne Cheyenne Johnson. Plus: demon dating experiences, remembering Lorraine Warren, and a few minutes about the Snatch Game.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Apr 24, 2019 at 4:47am PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Ed and Lorraine Warren
2. The Smurl family
3. The Duplex on Chase St
4. Paranormal Activity in the Smurl home
5. Press outside the Smurl home
6. Arne Cheyenne Johnson on his way to trial
7. Courtroom sketch of Arne Johnson on trial
8. Debbie Glatzel & Arne Cheyenne Johnson – present day

Delicious is a state of mind! This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the unsolved murder of Dorothy Jane Scott, and the mystery of This Man. Plus: gender reveal party mayhem, Elvira’s forgotten sitcom, and Canadian conflict resolution.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Apr 16, 2019 at 10:05pm PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Dorothy Jane Scott
2. Dorothy and her son, Shawn
3. Article about the discovery of Dorothy’s remains
4. This Man
5. This Man poster in Brazil
6. Guru Siddhar Ulagam’s website
7. Andrea Natella’s profile picture

Welcome to ‘Murder He Squealed.’ This week, Johnny and Tyler discuss the case of Estefanía Gutiérrez Lázaro, as well as the crimes of Leopold and Loeb. Plus: why book burnings are passé, a quick Drag Race recap, and something you might not know about your dad.

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Apr 9, 2019 at 9:20pm PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Estefanía Gutiérrez Lázaro
2. Concepcion Lázaro
3. The younger sisters’ bedroom
4. Burnt portrait of Estefanía
5. Bobby Franks
6. Where Bobby’s body was found
7. The glasses
8. Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb
9. The courtroom

Get off the desk! This week, Tyler and Johnny cover Hellish Nell, Britain’s last witch, and the king of the pool mannequins, Herbert Baumeister. Plus: a murder confession at McDonalds, LSD water in a Missouri workplace, and the Monster Ball!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Apr 3, 2019 at 5:04am PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Helen Duncan aka Hellish Nell
2. Helen and her spirit guide ‘Peggy’
3. Helen emerging from her cabinet
4. News article covering her trial
5. Wanted poster for Herbert Baumeister
6. Herb Baumeister, Mr. Pool Mannequins himself
7. Fox Hollow Farm
8. Herbert’s infamous pool (sans mannequins)

Hey, I just met you and this is crazy. This week, Johnny and Tyler talk about the horrifying case of Carl Tanzler and the Granny Ripper, Tamara Samsonova. Plus: haunted bedroom sets for sale, Cheetos on the runway, and when it’s appropriate to jam!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Mar 26, 2019 at 9:01pm PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Carl Tanzler (having a short shorts moment)
2. Maria Elena Milagro de Hoyos
3. Maria’s body after Carl ‘reconstructed’ her
4. Maria’s glass eye
5. Carl’s spaceship that was supposed to bring Maria back to life
6. Valentina Ulanova
7. Tamara Samsonova’s apartment
8. Samsonova caught on security footage
9. Tamara Samsonova blowing kisses to the press after her arrest

We’re not here for any unfinished business. That’s dumb! This week, Tyler and Johnny discuss the complex case of Shiva Tripathi and Sumitra Singh, and the murder of Scott Amedure (aka ‘the Jenny Jones murder’). Plus: a terrifying library gost (their spelling, not ours), child letter writing, and diva worship!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That's Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Mar 19, 2019 at 10:11pm PDT

(Swipe to see all photos)

Photos in order after cover:
1. Letter from the Fredericton ‘Library Gost’
2. Shiva Tripathi
3. Sumitra Singh
4. Scott Amedure
5. Scott greeting Jonathan Schmitz on the Jenny Jones Show
6. Scott and Jonathan
7. Jonathan Schmitz: human skid mark