Mermaids and vampires and bears, oh my! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the Deerness Mermaid and the Mercy Brown Vampire Incident. Plus: YouTube ghosts, Netflix’s oopsie poopsie, and a haunted Elsa doll that just won’t let it go!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Jan 21, 2020 at 9:00pm PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Old map of Orkney
2. Aerial shot of Newark Bay and Deerness (by M. Pennington)
3. Drawing of the Deerness Mermaid
4. Drawing of a Finman
5. Satirical cartoon published in Boston Daily Globe about Rhode Island Vampires
6. The tomb where Mercy Brown was interred
7. Mercy Brown’s grave

Still feeling that big lighthouse energy? This week Tyler and Johnny discuss Mona Fandey and the haunted history of the Gibraltar Point Lighthouse. Plus: Knives by The Killer, AJ and the Queen, and emo history!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Jan 14, 2020 at 11:25pm PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Mona Fandey during her attempted pop career
2. Inside Fandey’s home
3. Mazlan Idris
4. Mohd Affandi Abdul Rahman (top) and Juraimi Hussin (bottom)
5. Fandey & Rahman in custody
6. Gibraltar Point Lighthouse in present-day
7. The lighthouse keeper’s cabin
8. George Durnan being interviewed by John Ross Robertson
9. DeeDee Dodds

Are you ready for a luxury experience? This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the possession of Martha Brossier and the Smalls Lighthouse Tragedy. Plus: dead motels, Family Feud, and a Ghost Studies course that has everyone talking!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Jan 8, 2020 at 12:12am PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Painting of a renaissance exorcism (artist unknown)
2. Cover for the first published account of Martha’s story (modern cover)
3. Romorantin, France in present-day
4. King Henry IV of France
5. Depiction of the original Smalls Lighthouse
6. Map showing the location of the Smalls Lighthouse
7. A rendering and description of the Smalls Lighthouse
8. The original Smalls Lighthouse next to the one built in 1861
9. The 1861 Smalls Lighthouse, which still stands today

Ding dong, darling, ding dong! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Fox Sisters and the case of Katarzyna Zowada. Plus: reflections on the new year, getting dangerously trolled by Alexa, and new ways to accessorize with clip-on earrings!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Jan 1, 2020 at 5:45pm PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. The Hydesville Cottage
2. The Fox Sisters: Maggie and Kate
3. Maggie, Kate, and Leah
4. Katarzyna Zowada
5. Police sketch of the remains found in January 1999 (we decided not the share the actual photo, which is out there)
6. The recently arrested suspect that is facing charges

We’re here for frickin’ love! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Slit-Mouthed Woman (Kuchisake-Onna) and the Baldoon Mystery. Plus: Christmas Evil, and we discuss the new infamous true crime documentary that has everyone talking!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Dec 25, 2019 at 4:37pm PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Kuchisake-Onna in Carved (2007)
2. Conversation Diagram of Kuchisake-Onna
3. Old map showing Baldoon settlement
4. Illustration of the McDonald farm
5. Local headline about the mystery
6. More press about the mystery
7. A marker on the former site of the farm

Get ready for a blow out! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss Krampus and The Cage in Saint Osyth. Plus: extreme embalming, a mild distaste for Hallmark movies, and an old-time Christmas tradition we’d like to see come back!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Dec 18, 2019 at 1:25pm PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Illustration of Krampus at work
2. A contemporary Krampus Run
3. Statue of a Pagan Wild Man
4. Lady Krampus
5. Krampus lookin’ cute
6. The Cage in St. Osyth
7. A marker outside The Cage
8. The remains found in 1921
9. Debbie transformed into a Hag

Consider yourself read! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Spider Man of Denver and the legend of Edward Mordrake. Plus: darksided Devil lips, a little a bit of swinging, and some closure on a story we’ve discussed in the past!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Dec 11, 2019 at 2:40am PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. The Peter Home
2. Theodore Coney
3. The Peters’ attic
4. Sketch of Edward Mordrake from 1895 article
5. The famous Edward Mordrake photo
6. Wax figure of Edward Mordrake
7. Papier-mâché interpretation of Mordrake’s skull

Hold on to your homemade wig! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the Beast of Jersey and Soap-Maker of Correggio, Leonarda Cianciulli. Plus: a $1 hotel with strings attached, a bit of realness, and an update on what Cher’s been up to lately!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Dec 4, 2019 at 3:13am PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Jersey pointed out on a map
2. Edward Paisnel
3. Beast of Jersey disguise
4. Close up of the Beast’s mask
5. Young Leonarda
6. Leonarda’s victims
7. Leonarda during arrest
8. Evidence found at Leonarda’s home

Baby, I’m burning! This week Tyler and Johnny discuss the Chase Vault and the ballad of the Knoxville Girl. Plus: Krampus krafts, celebrating the finale of Drag Race UK, and PeePee PooPoo Man is at large in Toronto (for real)!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Nov 27, 2019 at 12:39am PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. The Chase Vault
2. The Chase Vault Interior
3. Diagram of shifting coffins
4. Modern Day Christ Church, Barbados
5. Aerial map of Knoxville, TN from 1871
6. Cover of ‘Tragic Songs of Life’ by The Louvin Brothers
7. Copy of the original ‘Bloody Miller’ ballad sheet
8. Portrait of Samuel Pepys (looking like Natasha Lyonne)

I don’t wanna call no names! This week Johnny and Tyler discuss the Circleville Letter Writer and the Hello Kitty murder. Plus: makeup tutorials and true crime together at last, ghosts getting busy, and a forgotten graveyard discovered in Florida!

Please consider supporting the show on Patreon for access to mini episodes and many more perks! patreon.com/thatsspooky

Check us out on Twitter at @thatsspookypod

Follow us on Instagram for photos from today’s episode and more @thatsspookypod

Don’t forget to send your spooky stories to thatsspookypod@gmail.com

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by That’s Spooky (@thatsspookypod) on Nov 20, 2019 at 12:09am PST

(Swipe to see all photos)

1. Aerial shot of Circleville, OH
2. One of the first Gillispie letters
3. Paul Freshour
4. Letter received by Freshour in prison
5. The Hello Kitty doll
6. Chan’s abandoned apartment
7. Fan Man-yee and her son
8. Leung Shing-Chon under arrest
9. Chan Man-lok hides face after sentencing